COVERS OF VIDEO GAME SONGS BY JAM BANDS, RATED
Video game music typically plays in short, repetitive loops. Jam bands poke and prod and stretch and expand their compositions in new and wild ways, with no two performances of a given song sounding exactly the same. If you love both, then in time, you will eventually arrive at the question: what if jam bands took some of those old classic video game chestnuts into the stratosphere? Some of them have. And by looking at those examples, you can actually begin to develop an understanding of why it doesn’t happen more often.
All song titles are [sic], because video game compositions often receive pretty shabby treatment when it comes to being called by their actual titles.
ULU, "SMB"
In my estimation, the crown jewel of jam band video game covers. A short, tight acid jazz medley. Perhaps it saw such popularity because, uncharacteristically for jam bands, it gets in and gets out (something we'll talk about more in this list). So widely disseminated that it got mislabeled as Phish on P2P file-sharing apps by people who have clearly never heard Phish. Later performances, like this one, include more songs, like the invincibility and castle themes, though I still prefer the Wetlands version's blistering brevity. I give this one five Nintendo cartridges.

DOPAPOD, "DONKEY KONG COUNTRY THEME"
[CW: flashing lights, if you actually watch the video rather than listen to it as background]
There was a time when I believed it was not possible to imagine something cooler than a jam band that covered video game songs. It seemed like such a natural slam dunk: you have a staggeringly deep catalog of tunes (40+ years) to pull from, and who wouldn’t want to hear a 23-minute "Aquatic Ambiance" or see how a group manages to pretzel a Castlevania song into segueing into something from Kirby? The answer should be obvious if you have more than a glancing familiarity with them: gamers, of course, would not want to hear that. I listened to a lot of performances of this song for this post, and that journey helped me realize why sustaining a video game jam band might pose more of a challenge in the long term than I initially took into account.
Video game music almost always plays, and is listened to, in a specific context. It’s designed to match the pace, atmosphere, or biome of a level—sometimes all three at once. Or it might emphasize the mood of a cutscene. People listening to video game music outside of that context are, speaking generally, not interested in exploring untrod sonic frontiers. They want to relive a moment. They crave the numbing comfort of familiarity. If you borrow a classic game tune and snap it in half to use as bookends for a Type II jam, you’re probably going to lose a lot of people who came to hear "Bob-Omb Battlefield".
That’s why I like the specific performance of the Donkey Kong Country theme I posted below so much. That was the first time I ever heard them do this song, and it’s still my favorite, partly because it prominently features a sample from the game that helps anchor it and maintain the Donkey Kong Country identity even across an 11-minute runtime. It’s very easy for a jam built around a video game song to lose that throughline, if it even has it at all. It’s kind of jarring to hear at first, but I think it gets to work very quickly, in large part because drummer Neal Evans integrates it so seamlessly and lets it carry such a significant portion of the rhythm’s weight. There is a fun solo-ish moment where he bats it around like a cat toying with prey, which sort of evokes those viral videos where a drummer programs something really silly into their soundboard and cracks the band up by springing it on them without warning, but he doesn’t overplay the joke and reins it in before it can derail the jam.
This gets at the reason why a video game jam band probably wouldn’t work out so hot in the long run. The video game aspect and the jam aspect would be constantly competing with each other. When people go to see video game music performed live, they don’t turn to rock bands, they go to symphonic performances—tightly controlled, curated, rehearsed experiences that make the game (or franchise) the star of the night. With jam bands, a lot of songs—not all, but a lot—are merely foundational, skeletal structures that exist to be fleshed out by, and ultimately serve, the jam. Any pursuit that seeks to serve both masters is, sadly, likely to fail.
In general, I rate Dopey Pod Country four-and-a-half Nintendo cartridges, with the one I posted getting the full five.

Many of the bands on this list are no longer active as of this writing. Economic conditions have produced an environment that makes touring unsustainable for all but the top-tier groups in the scene. Among such bands, I would agree with those who say Dopapod is the best. Was the best. Hopefully one day will again be the best.
DOPAPOD, "DR. MARIO CHILL THEME"
Not a tune they covered as often as the Donkey Kong Country title theme, but still very much in their wheelhouse, and it gets nice and filthy very easily. Dr. Mario strikes a certain chord of fondness for me because my mom used to play it, and any time my parents got into a video game, it was worth sitting up and taking notice. She was kind of obsessed with it for a while, actually. We had it on both NES and Game Boy, and she would practice on the Game Boy version when she was sitting in the pick-up line waiting for my brother and I to get out of school, then dominate on the NES at home. She never played on any setting other than level 20 (the highest you can choose from the beginning) on high speed. When I pick it up nowadays, I usually start from the beginning on medium. I like to ease myself into the pool, so to speak; she always cannonballed right on in. I bet she could pick it up now and only need minimal de-rusting. I should see about this at Thanksgiving.
Oh yeah, we were talking about something else, weren’t we? Yeah, it’s good.

AQUEOUS, "SARIA'S SONG"
Like the Ulu Mario medley, this one accomplishes everything it needs to do in about two minutes, which is especially impressive here, because Aqueous were one of those bands that really liked egregiously running up the clock on a song. It starts off quiet and pretty and just gets progressively heavier over the course of two minutes. You would never believe you could hear a version of “Saria’s Song” that would make you want to punch a hole through a sheet of drywall until you heard this. Solid work. Four Nintendo cartridges.

QUAGMIRE SWIM TEAM, "ZELDA UNDERWORLD"
This is a band I think not even a lot of super plugged-in heads might recognize. I remember seeing them around back in my earliest days of discovering the Internet Archive, but they never clicked with me the way other bands did. Still, they jammed, they were around for a hot second, and they have a video game song in their repertoire, so that’s good enough to make this list. This one pops up a lot in their sets, but it's only ever a brief appearance.
Unlike the Ulu and Aqueous picks, this feels undercooked. There's nothing wrong with it being a short diversion, but the other two bands took steps to develop their songs in a unique direction. QST just kind of careens through the dungeon theme for a minute like a track runner who trips over one hurdle and suddenly is tripping over all of them. But in the jam world, bands often establish what tier they're going to live comfortably in for the rest of their career very quickly and don't often move too far away from it in either direction. QST just never had "it", I think.

DISCO BISCUITS, "DUCKTALES MOON THEME"
(Melody starts at 1:05.)
I’ve always felt like the Disco Biscuits manage to sound incredibly virtuosic and incredibly half-assed at the same time. This cover falls very much in line with that assessment. However, like Aqueous, they also manage to restrain themselves from letting it go too long, perhaps even more surprisingly so in their case. It also doesn’t stray too far from the main melody, lending credence to the idea that throwing such tunes into a set is a bit of a cheap pop and that melody recognition usually wins out over sonic exploration in those cases. Three Nintendo cartridges.

I've also seen some sources call this "DuckTales Moon Board". Sorry, but if you call a video game level a "board", I think you're stinky and I don't like you.
PAPADOSIO ARCADE SET, SECRET DREAMS FESTIVAL 2022/09/18
This is the ultimate example, for this topic, of getting exactly what you think you want and realizing it’s not so awesome after all. Some of the draw of jam bands is the guarantee of seeing something special unspool in real time, warts and all. It’s such a baked-in feature of the scene that moe. named an entire series of curated live releases Warts and All. There can be a lot of charm in a ramshackle performance, but sometimes that veers from (complimentary) to (derogatory), and I feel like that’s what happened here. “Aquatic Ambiance”, from Donkey Kong Country, is, somewhat surprisingly, the briefest track in the set—one would imagine its, uh, aquatic ambiance would lend it to a very jammy sort of meandering—but as I feel it’s somewhat overrepresented in video game music remembrance, I posted another song I enjoyed from the set that doesn’t get its due flowers as often.

Honorable Mention: MAGIC BEANS, "JABU JABU'S BELLY"
This one is an honorable mention because it is not actually a cover of an Ocarina of Time song. It's just called "Jabu Jabu's Belly". But it is a great jam from the Magic Beans' second release, a double album called Sites & Sounds. Each disc's vibe differed wildly from the other's; Sites had more acoustic barnburners, while Sounds was spacier and mellower. In addition, jams from young Beans meandered a lot more than their later, comparatively more focused stuff. "Jabu Jabu's Belly" actually counts as a pretty tight jam for early Beans; at 8 minutes and 10 seconds, it is somehow the third-shortest track across the 13 offerings on Sites & Sounds. Since it's not a video game song, I will instead rate it on how likely I would be to mute Ocarina of Time and listen to this song when playing that dungeon instead. By that metric, I give it three-and-a-half Nintendo cartridges.
